Introduction
Learning a language is a hard task. Some say that kids should learn
a second language at an early age. Others think that kids should
wait until they are older to study a new language. Today our debaters
will discuss whether all kids should learn a second language at
an early age.
Constructive
Debater 1 Henry
All kids should learn a second language at an early age. Research
shows that a child’s brain goes through an important stage early
on when it is more open to learning information. Secondly, an adult
has spent more time speaking their native language. Therefore, their
brain is already fixed to use their first language. However, a child’s
brain is more flexible. That’s why it is easy for them to accept
new grammar rules.
Debater
2 Ashley
All kids should not learn a second language at an early age. It
is a myth that young children are better than adults or adolescents
at learning second languages. Children are only better at learning
pronunciation. However, kids can learn grammar rules and vocabulary
better when they are older. It is actually harder for children because
they have not learned different ways to memorize new words or grammar
rules.
Rebuttal
Debater 1 Henry
Kids should learn a second language at an early age so that they
can have good pronunciation. Scientific studies show that kids who
learn a language early have a better accent. Also, young children
who learn a second language early think that learning a new language
is normal and natural. On the other hand, adolescents and adults
often are embarrassed to make a mistake. They are also shyer to
speak the new language.
Debater
2 Ashley
You said that there is a time when kids are more open to learning
different types of information. During this time, I think kids should
focus on learning their native language. It is good to learn a new
language. However, it is most important for kids to speak their
native language well. An adult should already speak their language
fluently. Therefore, they are ready to learn a new language.
Judge’s
Comments
The winner of today’s debate is Henry. Ashley said that it is a
myth that young children are better than adults or adolescents at
learning second languages. However, she did not provide enough evidence
in her argument to support her claim. It is important to support
your claims with evidence.